GST Taxation:Time Place and Value of Supply

GST (Goods and Services Tax) simplifies taxation by streamlining it into three types: SGST and CGST for intra-state transactions, and IGST for inter-state transactions. But determining whether a transaction is within the state or across states can be tricky.

Consider scenarios like online training sessions with participants worldwide or hotel services where guests may have offices in different states or goods sold during train journeys through multiple states.

To address these complexities, the IGST Act provides rules known as “place of supply rules.” These rules help determine whether a transaction is within a state or across states, ensuring accurate taxation.

Significance of Time Place and Value of Supply in GST

Understanding the time, place, and value of supply is crucial in GST for several reasons:

• Time of Supply: This indicates when goods/services are considered to be supplied. Knowing this helps sellers determine when taxes are due for payment.

• Place of Supply: Determines which tax—IGST for inter-state or CGST/SGST for intra-state transactions—should be charged on the invoice.

• Value of Supply: GST is calculated based on the value of the sale. Accurate calculation of this value ensures correct GST charges. Incorrect valuation can lead to incorrect GST amounts being charged.

Time of Supply in GST

Time of supply refers to when goods or services are officially considered to be provided. Knowing this time helps sellers determine when they need to pay taxes.

Under GST, CGST/SGST or IGST must be paid when the supply occurs. The time of supply differs for goods and services. Let’s explore these in detail.

Time of Supply for Goods

The time of supply for goods is determined by the earliest of the following:

1. The date when the invoice is issued.
2. The last date by which the invoice should have been issued.
3. The date when advance payment is received.

This helps businesses identify when they need to pay taxes on goods supplied under GST.

Example of Time of Supply Analysis

Let’s understand the time of supply in a scenario:

Mr. X sells goods worth Rs 1,00,000 to Mr. Y. The invoice is issued on 15th January, payment is received on 31st January, and the goods are supplied on 20th January.

Determining the time of supply involves finding the earliest event:

• Date of invoice issuance: 15th January
• Last date for invoice issuance: 20th January

In this case, the time of supply is 15th January.

Now, if Mr. X receives an advance of Rs 50,000 on 1st January:

• Time of supply for the advance: 1st January
• For the remaining Rs 50,000: 15th January

This demonstrates how the time of supply is determined based on the earliest event, ensuring accurate taxation under GST.

Time of Supply for Services

Determining the time of supply for services involves considering the earliest event:

1. Date of invoice issuance
2. Date of receipt of advance/payment
3. Date of service provision (if invoice not issued within a set period)

Let’s illustrate this with an example:

Mr. A provides services worth Rs 20,000 to Mr. B on 1st January. The invoice is issued on 20th January, and payment is received on 1st February.

Since the invoice is issued within the prescribed time limit (30 days from the date of supply), we compare the date of invoice issuance and the date of payment.

In this case:

• Date of invoice issuance: 20th January
• Date of payment: 1st February

Thus, the time of supply for services is 20th January, as it is the earliest event among the options.

Time of Supply under Reverse Charge

In the case of the reverse charge mechanism, the time of supply for the service receiver is determined by the earliest event:

1. Date of payment
2. 30 days from the date of invoice issuance for goods (60 days for services)

It’s important to note that as per Notification No. 66/2017 – Central Tax, effective from 15th November 2017, ‘Date of Payment’ is not applicable for goods and only applies to services.

For instance:
M/s ABC Pvt. Ltd avails services of a director, Mr. X, worth Rs. 50,000 on 15th January. The invoice is raised on 1st February, and M/s ABC Pvt Ltd makes the payment on 1st May.

In this scenario, the time of supply is determined by comparing:

• Date of payment: 1st May
• 60 days from the date of invoice issuance: 2nd April

Since the payment date is earlier, the time of supply for services is considered to be 1st May.

Place of Supply

Understanding the concept of “place of supply” is crucial for correctly determining the applicable tax to be charged on an invoice.

For example:

Place of Supply for Goods

Typically, for goods, the place of supply is where the goods are delivered. It’s where ownership of the goods changes hands.

However, if there’s no physical movement of goods, the place of supply becomes the location where the goods are at the time of delivery to the recipient.

For instance, in a supermarket sale, the place of supply is the supermarket itself.

In cases where goods are assembled or installed, the place of supply is where the installation occurs. For example, if machinery from Kolkata is installed in a Kanpur factory, then Kanpur becomes the place of supply for that machinery.

Place of Supply for Services

In general, the place of supply for services is where the service recipient is located.

However, if services are provided to an unregistered dealer whose location is unknown, the place of supply defaults to the location of the service provider.

Special rules apply for specific services like those related to immovable property, restaurant services, event admissions, transportation, telecom, and banking/financial/insurance services.

For services related to immovable property, like interior designing for a property in a different location, the place of supply is where the property is situated.

For instance:

• Mr. Anil from Delhi provides interior designing services for a property in Ooty, Tamil Nadu. In this case, the place of supply is Ooty, Tamil Nadu.

Similarly, for passenger transport services where passengers don’t have GST registration, the place of supply is where the journey begins.

• For example, if a taxpayer offers transport services from Bangalore to Hampi, the place of supply is Bangalore, where the journey commences.

Value of Supply for Goods or Services

The value of supply refers to the money the seller intends to collect for the goods or services provided. Essentially, it’s the amount paid by the buyer to the seller.

However, in cases where parties are related or where transactions occur through barter or exchange, GST law mandates the use of ‘transactional value.’ This is the value at which unrelated parties would normally conduct similar transactions. It ensures proper GST assessment, even if the full value hasn’t been paid.

Go to Accounts Profession Homepage for the Latest Information.